Best roofers in Columbus, OH, according to ChatGPT and Gemini

We asked ChatGPT and Gemini 3 questions people in Columbus ask about roofers, and counted every business they named. Checked Oct 20, 2026.

Check your own business free

Named most often

6 AI answers · Columbus, OH · Roofing

FORM NS-LOH

Muth & Company RoofingChatGPT 2× · Gemini 1×3 of 6
Newman RoofingChatGPT 1× · Gemini 2×3 of 6
Able RoofChatGPT 0× · Gemini 2×2 of 6
FeazelChatGPT 0× · Gemini 2×2 of 6
Brothers Roofing and ConstructionChatGPT 1× · Gemini 0×1 of 6
Best Roofing and Siding CompanyChatGPT 1× · Gemini 0×1 of 6
Able RoofingChatGPT 0× · Gemini 1×1 of 6
Roof MedicChatGPT 0× · Gemini 1×1 of 6
Next Level Roofing of ColumbusChatGPT 0× · Gemini 1×1 of 6
Roof King & RestorationChatGPT 0× · Gemini 1×1 of 6

The questions we asked

“Who is the best roofer in Columbus, OH?”
“Which roofing company in Columbus, OH has the best reviews?”
“I need a roof replacement in Columbus, OH. Who should I call?”

Websites AI quoted

bbb.org1×
brothersroofingconstruction.com1×
portal.columbus.gov1×
columbustoprated.com1×
theroofingbrief.com1×

What AI looks at for roofers

State contractor license number on the site
Google reviews that mention roof replacement and repair by name
Angi, BBB and HomeAdvisor profiles
Manufacturer certifications (GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed)
Storm and insurance-claim pages

In their own words

ChatGPT, asked “I need a roof replacement in Columbus, OH. Who should I call?”

I’d start with Muth & Company Roofing—they’ve served Central Ohio for decades, handle roof replacements, and are BBB-accredited with an A+ rating. Call (614) 882-0900. ([bbb.org](https://www.bbb.org/us/oh/westerville/profile/roofing-contractors/muth-co-roofing-inc-0302-37001885)) For a second quote, try Brothers Roofing and Construction: (614) 436-5588. They advertise roof replacement, insurance, and a City of Columbus contractor license. ([brothersroofingconstruction.com](https://www.brothersroofingconstruction.com/)) Before signing, get three written estimates and compare the tear-off scope, underlayment, ventilation, cleanup, warranty, and payment schedule. If the home is within Columbus city limits, verify the contractor’s current license through the city’s contractor search. ([portal.columbus.gov](https://portal.columbus.gov/Permits/GeneralProperty/PropertyLookUp.aspx?TabName=HOME…

Gemini, asked “I need a roof replacement in Columbus, OH. Who should I call?”

Replacing a roof is a big project, so it's smart to want a reliable contractor. Fortunately, Columbus has some excellent local roofing companies with great reputations. Here are a few highly-rated businesses you should definitely consider calling for a quote: Able Roofing: They are practically an institution in Central Ohio. They are known for their efficiency—often finishing a residential roof replacement in just one day—and they offer solid, long-lasting warranties. Roof Medic: Locals frequently recommend this team for their honesty and transparency. If you want a contractor who will give you a straightforward assessment without high-pressure sales tactics, they are a fantastic choice. Next Level Roofing of Columbus: They have a strong reputation and an A rating with the Better Business Bureau. Reviewers often praise their excellent communication, punctuality, and quality workmans…

Is your business on this list?

Run the free check for your own roofer business in Columbus. It asks the same kind of questions and shows how often AI names you, who it names instead, and what to fix. No card, no account.

AI referral check

Free. About a minute. No card, no account.

FORM NS-1No. 875031

Business name

Website optional

Trade

City

State

Compare with up to 2 rivals optional

Email for your copy

We ask ChatGPT and Gemini 5 real customer questions, 2 times each, using OpenAI’s and Google’s models with live web search, asked directly (the ChatGPT and Gemini apps can answer differently). One free check per business per month.

Form NS-1 · Rev 10/26 · White copy to you, canary to us

Roofers and AI search: common questions

Which roofers does AI recommend most in Columbus, OH?

In 6 ChatGPT and Gemini answers checked Oct 20, 2026, the roofers named most often were Muth & Company Roofing (3 of 6), Newman Roofing (3 of 6), Able Roof (2 of 6). AI answers change from one ask to the next, so treat this as a snapshot; we refresh it monthly.

Which websites does AI quote about roofers in Columbus?

In this check the assistants cited bbb.org (1 times), brothersroofingconstruction.com (1 times), portal.columbus.gov (1 times), columbustoprated.com (1 times). Being listed accurately on the sites AI quotes is one of the most direct ways to start being named.

Why does ChatGPT recommend some roofers and not others?

It leans on what it can verify on the web: a state license number on the roofer’s own site, Google reviews that mention roof replacement or storm repair by name, and profiles on Angi, BBB and HomeAdvisor. Roofers with little written about them online rarely get named, however good their work is.

Do manufacturer certifications help a roofer get recommended by AI?

They can. GAF, Owens Corning and CertainTeed keep public directories of certified contractors, and assistants with web search often quote those lists. A certification only helps if it is current and shown on the roofer’s site as well.

Does AI know which roofers handle insurance claims?

Only when the roofer says so in writing. A page that explains how the company works with insurance after hail or wind damage, and reviews that mention claims, give the assistant something to quote when a homeowner asks.

Can a roofing company pay to appear in ChatGPT or Gemini answers?

No. There is no paid placement in these answers today. What moves the needle is the same public information a careful homeowner would check: license, reviews, directory profiles and clear service pages.

How this list is made: each question is sent to the assistant with web search on, the way a customer would ask it. We count a business each time it is named. AI answers vary between asks; this is a snapshot, refreshed monthly. Not a paid ranking, and no business can pay to be listed. Weekly tracking for your own business: see plans.